Unit/department managers at Champlain Valley Physicians Hospital (CVPH) in Plattsburgh, N.Y., used to spend an inordinate amount of time dealing with scheduling and staffing issues. This is a common and frustrating problem for hospital managers. In fact, staffing tasks—such as developing schedules, struggling with paper processes like paid time off (PTO), tracking licensure and credentialing details, complying with union regulations, or trying to recruit staff to fill open shifts—can occupy 50 percent or more of a manager’s time, according to anecdotal reports.In 2010, the 381-bed CVPH moved to a centralized approach to staffing and scheduling for nursing and other departments, such as pharmacy and respiratory therapy. It also replaced manual and, at times, paper-based processes with automated scheduling solutions. A time study of inpatient nursing units revealed a return of 7 hours of work per manager for every pay period. Managers have been able to redirect their time from scheduling activities to patient care and staff mentoring.
One challenge many healthcare organizations struggle with is a silo approach to labor management, which usually involves a director or manager controlling the unit’s scheduling, deployment, and administrative duties. At first glance, allowing managers to administer those functions may seem like a good idea because they are familiar with the work performed and the skills of staff members on each shift. However, in the end, managers find themselves spending too much time planning and handling day-of-shift chaos that results from last-minute call-ins or scheduling errors. In addition, the silo approach to labor management can result in overstaffed units sending staff home while similar units run short on staff and need to use overtime or bring in more expensive, last-minute sources of external staffing. The end result is excessive overtime and the use of temporary employees because the system is unable to effectively coordinate resources.By centralizing resource management, deployment, and alignment strategies at the enterprise level, organizations can leverage economies of scale and use real-time coordination of staffing to use on-hand resources effectively. This concept is not reserved solely for large, multi-site organizations. Economies of scale increase the larger the organization is, but stand-alone organizations, like CVPH, have seen tremendous benefits from the coordination of resources, the consistent and fair application of policies, and efficient deployment of contingency staff. CVPH’s resource management center is a 24/7 operation that balances schedules, ensures staff are scheduled to their FTE, proactively identifies upcoming gaps in the schedule, and handles administrative duties previously carried out on the unit. The resource management center works directly with the clinical decision makers (typically the house supervisors), providing them with the most up-to-date understanding of the entire staffing picture.
Many of CVPH’s staffing efficiencies are the result of the hospital’s scheduling software. CVPH’s staff resources can be viewed in real-time across the organization so managers can make quick and accurate decisions without having to consult different systems, spreadsheets, or scheduling data. For example, the following illustration shows the impact of staffing decisions in both dollars and hours.
The scheduling software allows CVPH staff members to submit scheduling and time-off requests electronically. Once a staff member submits a request, a manager is sent a notification that automatically shows the impact the request will have on staffing. As soon as the request is approved, the schedule is updated as shown in the following illustration.
Notifications are sent to staff members. In addition, the changes are transmitted to CVPH’s time-and-attendance system, eliminating the need for double entry of information and diminishing the likelihood of data entry errors. CVPH also made sure that its scheduling software would integrate with existing systems, such as the organization’s time-and-attendance software and systems that track:
Ensuring integration with other systems in the organization eliminates the need for paper-based workarounds.
An open shift management protocol should be configurable to allow for an almost limitless number of rules and protocols, such as those governing:
For example, CVPH required customization of its open shift management to accommodate its business and union rules. At CVPH, once a cyclic schedule is copied and pushed forward for future shifts its staff members are able to self-schedule and use the automated system to fill holes in the schedule and meet their FTE requirements. Following this, the system uses a seniority-based, equitable process of filling the remaining shifts.
The success CVPH has experienced is a direct result of its effort to transform its culture, as well as adopt new processes and technologies. The path to transformational change, like CVPH experienced, is a succession of small steps, with three major components:
Change is difficult for any organization, and it is impossible for organizations that do not want to change and don’t see the value. This need for change is what must be communicated effectively. CVPH was successful in its transition to an enterprise staffing model because its leadership and staff alike understood that their previous approach to managing labor resources was not effective, resulted in too many errors, and was not sustainable given the changes that the healthcare industry was and is facing.CVPH’s enterprise model for automated staffing delivered enormous returns both in dollars and in managers’ time. The staffing software created a framework for repeatable outcomes that are in line with CVPH’s goals and provide managers with the time to focus on their responsibilities to their patients and staff.
Jackie Larson is senior vice president of client services, Avantas, Omaha, Neb. (JLarson@eavantas.com).Rhonda Kowalowski is supervisor, patient services, Champlain Valley Physicians Hospital, Plattsburgh, N.Y. (RKowalowski@cvph.org).
J.P. Morgan: Managing Cybersecurity and Protecting Patient Data
Brian DiPietro, Managing Director, Commercial Bank Technology, JPMorgan Chase & Co., discusses the importance of evaluating your cybersecurity protocols to help prevent malicious data breaches.
TransUnion Healthcare: Smarter Revenue Cycle Solutions
Gerry McCarthy, President of TransUnion Healthcare, discusses industry trends contributing to higher bad debt and what to do about them. Gerry is responsible for the strategic direction of the healthcare business and expanding its footprint in the healthcare market overall. He has more than 20 years of experience in healthcare information technologies.
Deloitte: Creating Value with Effective Care Management
Scott Kolesar, principal and senior leader in Deloitte Consulting LLP's Value Based Care practice, and David Wennberg, MD, MPH, adjunct associate professor of The Dartmouth Institute and former chief executive officer, Northern New England Accountable Care Collaborative, discuss the challenges and competencies involved in creating a care management organization.
American Express: Streamlining Supplier Payments and Boosting Revenue
Andrew Jamison, vice president in the Global Corporate Payments division of American Express, discusses trends and opportunities in supplier payments.
Deloitte: Realizing the Potential of Your CDI Program
Suzanne Whitworth, director at Deloitte & Touche LLP, and LaVerne Romberger, MSN, CCM, CCDS, clinical operations manager-Seton Healthcare, share leading practices for maximizing the potential of clinical documentation programs under value-based care.
RevSpring: Customizing a Technology Platform to Drive Patient Payment
Martin Callahan, Senior Vice President, Healthcare Solutions, RevSpring, describes key industry trends affecting how patients engage with the revenue cycle and ways payment processes are changing as a result.
KPMG: Readying for Healthcare Today and Tomorrow
Dion Sheidy, a partner in KPMG's Healthcare Advisory practice, discusses healthcare's changing landscape and how having the right advisor can help organizations navigate challenges and opportunities.
Huron Healthcare: Readying Your Organization for Transformation
Gordon Mountford, executive vice president, Huron Healthcare, discusses business imperatives for undertaking transformative change.
Xtend Healthcare: A Custom Approach to Optimizing Revenue Cycle Performance
Tom O'Neill, CEO of Xtend Healthcare Advanced Revenue Solutions, discusses key areas where organizations risk revenue leakage and ways they can use outsourcing to better protect cash flow and support accurate payment.
KeyBank: Helping You to Realize Your Strategic Vision in Changing Times
Victoria Terekhova, senior strategist for Enterprise Healthcare at KeyBank, discusses key challenges when developing long-term strategy in a rapidly changing industry, and the role the right banking partner can play in helping healthcare providers navigate the opportunities before them.