Ingalls Health System, serving Chicago’s south suburbs, is a one-hospital system with annual revenues of more than $300 million. Ingalls just opened its fifth outpatient clinic, and about 55 percent of revenues now come from outpatient services.
That means Ingalls is well-positioned for the future, said Andrew Stefo, senior vice president and CFO. “We think ambulatory is where the profitability lies, and it dovetails very well with the accountable care philosophy, which includes moving to a more cost-effective model,” he said.
He and other Ingalls leaders believe that a health system’s size should be measured not by its inpatient capacity but by the number of lives managed and the effectiveness of that management. They used that perspective to consider how to grow—and decided that merging with another organization held little appeal.
Ingalls’ analysis considered these factors:
Thus, for the foreseeable future, Ingalls’ board has chosen to remain independent. But that does not mean maintaining the status quo. “If you are going to remain independent, you are going to have to be more innovative than larger organizations,” Stefo said. “You cannot mirror someone who is bigger than you are and hope to survive that type of competitive landscape.”
To address marketplace challenges, Ingalls has developed strategic relationships with other organizations. For example, Ingalls serves low-income neighborhoods that are associated with high 30-day readmission rates, leading to a nearly 1 percent penalty on Medicare revenues. Most of its local competitors have the same problem, which is exacerbated by the fact that patients bounce from one hospital to the next, making it difficult to track readmissions, let alone manage those patients’ care.
To address these issues, Ingalls teamed with four competing hospitals in one of the Community Care Transitions programs supported by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Staff was hired by Catholic Charities to connect with recently discharged patients from all five hospitals to help avoid readmissions. At this early stage, the program looks to be effective, Stefo said.
In a bid to achieve scale without merging, Ingalls is also working with other independent systems across the Chicago market to build the Founders Network. Still under development, the network’s goal is to create a vehicle in which several health systems can jointly enter into shared-savings contracts with commercial payers without violating antitrust laws.
Ingalls also recently became an affiliate member of Catholic Contracting Group (CCG), an alliance of six Catholic health systems that combine their purchasing power to get the best prices from their group purchasing organization. In addition to lower supply prices, CCG also helps its affiliates narrow the range of orthopedic implants and other physician preference items they purchase. The CCG relationship helps Ingalls communicate with its physicians about how the standardization of devices and implants both improves quality and reduces costs. In the first year, Ingalls saved more than $800,000 on physician preference items.
As the healthcare industry restructures itself, the forces encouraging consolidation are not likely to dissipate soon, and every organization’s board should analyze the options and set the strategic direction. A wait-and-see approach may allow competitors to decide an organization’s fate.
“As I have told our board, if you want me to sell the hospital, I could write a work plan for that. If you want me to merge, I could write a work plan for that. If you want me to acquire another provider, I could write you a work plan for that,” Stefo said. “And if you want to remain independent, there is a work plan for that, and we have to be very realistic about what that means.”
Even as Ingalls leadership works its stay-independent plan, Stefo constantly monitors the competitive landscape, prepared to pivot if changes occur that jeopardize it. “We are very sensitive to the fact that the local marketplace is very fluid,” he said. “You have to continually reassess what’s going on and whether the tactics that you had adopted 18 months ago are still appropriate.”
Lola Butcher is a freelance writer and editor based in Missouri and a regular contributing writer to Leadership.
Quoted in this article: Andrew Stefo is senior vice president and CFO, Ingalls Health System, Harvey, Ill., and a member of HFMA’s First Illinois Chapter.
This article is an excerpt from a longer feature on mergers and affiliations in the Fall 2013 Leadership magazine.
Huron Healthcare: Readying Your Organization for Transformation
Gordon Mountford, executive vice president, Huron Healthcare, discusses business imperatives for undertaking transformative change.
Xtend Healthcare: A Custom Approach to Optimizing Revenue Cycle Performance
Tom O'Neill, CEO of Xtend Healthcare Advanced Revenue Solutions, discusses key areas where organizations risk revenue leakage and ways they can use outsourcing to better protect cash flow and support accurate payment.
KeyBank: Helping You to Realize Your Strategic Vision in Changing Times
Victoria Terekhova, senior strategist for Enterprise Healthcare at KeyBank, discusses key challenges when developing long-term strategy in a rapidly changing industry, and the role the right banking partner can play in helping healthcare providers navigate the opportunities before them.
SSI: Preparing the Revenue Cycle for Changing Payer Roles
Availity: Connect to the Future of Healthcare Information
Deloitte: Leveraging IT for Value-Based Care Transformation
Apex: Cultivating Patient Payment while Elevating the Patient Experience
HealthPort: Ensuring Compliant Exchange of Protected Health Information
Community Hospital Corporation: Supporting Community Hospitals
Cerner: Connecting Clinical and Financial Data
Aidin: Better Manage Your Post-Acute Provider Network and Improve Patient Outcomes
GE Healthcare: Delivering Sustainable Cost Reduction
Deloitte: Solutions for Healthcare Transformation