Browse by Topic
More than 40,000 members value HFMA's thought leadership and practical strategies. HFMA is where you need to be.
Get acquainted with the
healthcare finance industry's leading professional association. Find out why our
members rely on HFMA as their go-to source for insight and
Members have many
options for helping them advance their careers. Conferences, seminars,
eLearning, certification, and more -- our education and events will keep you
Connect the dots on today's big issues, explore collaborations, get career-boosting tips, and network with colleagues nationwide at the leading finance conference. Save $100 off the full conference rate when you register by May 8.
Real-time presentations with nationally recognized experts, networking opportunities, and industry solutions—no travel required!
Learn about timely healthcare finance topics and earn CPEs. Most live webinars are free for HFMA members and $99 for non-members. View the latest schedule.
If you're a subscriber to any of our three newsletters, you have access to online education. Learn more or subscribe.
Get the perspectives of leading healthcare finance professionals on today's hottest issues.
Information about leading vendors helps your buying decisions.
Forum members can network during live webinars or access a library of past webinars on topics such as bundled payment, charity care, and ICD-10.
An ever-expanding collection of spreadsheets, policies, job
descriptions, checklists, and more that you can adopt and adapt.
Forum members can submit vexing questions to a panel of experts
using our Ask the Expert service.
Your source for employment solutions.
Find new employment opportunities or
reach out to qualified candidates.
Distinguish yourself as a
leader among your peers and advance your career by earning certification in our
healthcare finance programs.
Get an objective third-party evaluation of products and services used in the healthcare finance workplace.
MAP App is a web-based application that helps organizations improve revenue cycle performance based on industry-standard metrics called MAP Keys.
Find suppliers and products in this comprehensive vendor directory for healthcare finance professionals.
Guidance for understanding and communicating about the price of health care.
Transformation toward value-based healthcare is reshaping the delivery of care, patient expectations, and payment structures.
Improve your revenue cycle performance through standard metrics, peer comparison, and successful practices.
By Lola Butcher
Ever since consumer-directed health plans emerged, payers and policymakers have been advocating for a transparent marketplace in which patients can make purchasing decisions based on cost and quality data. For many patients, that day has arrived. Insurers, state governments, and vendors are introducing online tools and other services that allow patients to easily compare costs of hospitals and physicians.
Much of the cost information being provided is pulled from claims data. A growing number of states and not-for-profit organizations, such as FAIR Health, have posted public databases that allow cost comparisons of common procedures/services, such as arthroscopic knee surgery. More sophisticated tools provide patients with tailored estimates that drill down into an individual's insurance plan, deductible, copays, etc.
This is still the experimentation stage of the healthcare transparency movement, says HFMA's Richard L. Gundling, FHFMA, CMA, vice president of healthcare financial practices. "It's evolving. Payers, providers, and patients are experimenting with information to see what will be used in decision making."
See related article: Lessons Learned from Hospital Transparency Pioneers
A number of health plans are experimenting with various approaches to encourage members to use cost information in choosing providers.
Online tools. Cigna recently launched an online service that allows health plan members to compare physicians and hospitals based on price for more than 200 medical procedures. The Cigna site also provides quality information on providers.
View Cigna screenshots
The Cigna service allows health plan members to assess medical costs, including specialist, facility, and ancillary fees. "You can look up a knee arthroscopy by doctor and get a precise estimate for what you will pay to get care through that doctor-that includes not just the doctor's fee, but also related services such as diagnostics and anesthesia, as well as hospital or facility costs," says Jim Nastri, Cigna's vice president for cost and quality transparency.
The service takes into account the patient's current deductible status and coinsurance responsibility and provides an estimate of the patient's payment responsibility. It also assesses the balance in the patient's health spending accounts.
The cost information is pulled from medical claims in the past year. Cigna claims that their tool has an accuracy rate of within 10 percent of the patient's cost 90 percent of the time.
Incentives for shopping. Harvard Pilgrim Health Care, with members in Massachusetts and New Hampshire, is providing financial incentives for members who search out lower-cost options for elective outpatient procedures and diagnostic tests. Members can call the insurer's SaveOn program before choosing a provider for a colonoscopy, CT scan, mammogram, or other service. A SaveOn nurse helps members identify the low-cost providers, helps with any paperwork needed to use those providers, and makes scheduling changes, if needed. In addition to lower out-of-pocket costs, members receive up to a $75 reward for using SaveOn, depending on the cost savings achieved.
Some Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield members in three states have access to a similar service called Compass SmartShopper. Members can find low-cost providers for certain diagnostic and elective services on a website or through a telephone call. Patients who choose a less-expensive provider than their physicians recommended will receive a check for between $50 and $200, depending on the savings.
Although the information that allows for comparison shopping is becoming available,
most patients are not yet choosing providers based on cost, says Gundling. Traditionally, most patients have relied heavily on so-called "trusted advisors" who recommend physicians and hospitals-and that continues to be an important influence on patient choices.
"That $100 or $50 difference in costs doesn't make as much difference as if your best friend had good results with a certain provider for the same procedure," says Gundling. "Patients think, 'I'll see that doctor, too.'"
A recent Health Affairs study backs up Gundling's assertion. Researchers cited several reasons for why patients are not accessing public cost reports ("Consumers' and Providers' Responses to Public Cost Reports, and How to Raise the Likelihood of Achieving Desired Results," Health Affairs, vol. 31, no. 4, April 2012):
Gundling compares healthcare purchasing decisions to the ways shoppers use a different value equation at Target than at Nordstrom. "Target and Nordstrom could offer the same silk scarf from the same manufacturer, but when you go to Nordstrom, you are willing to pay more for it-and you feel like you got better quality because you paid more for it," he says.
All of this likely explains why hospitals have not been at the forefront of cost transparency: Their patients are not demanding the information.
However, while most patients are not yet using cost to make high-value choices, they are gradually becoming more sophisticated consumers. "A couple years ago, not that many people were making distinctions between hospitals in terms of quality," says Joe Mondy, Cigna's director of public relations. "It was expected that quality was uniform or the quality for one type of procedure would be indicative of the hospital's quality for all types of procedures."
That is no longer the case. In developing its online tool, Cigna conducted focus group research that showed patients were very interested in quality scores when they were considering serious procedures that involved an inpatient stay, says Marie Jinks, Cigna's director of eBusiness. "When it came to a procedure that required an overnight hospital stay, patients really wanted to focus on the quality of both the doctor and the hospital where that particular procedure was performed," she says.
Based on that research, Cigna designed its online tool so that patients can see quality and cost ratings of physicians-and the various hospitals where those physicians work.
Gundling encourages hospital financial leaders to post cost or pricing information. Hospitals should encourage patients to become fully educated on their health plan benefits and what they can expect to pay for healthcare services.
Hospitals can help by providing information about a patient's expected financial obligations in writing-with appropriate caveats about what the pricing estimate does and does not include. "The first step is to provide something," he says. "If you can't provide any information, people are very distrustful."
Focus on making pricing information as simple as possible, Gundling continues, which will benefit patients as well as their employers and insurers. That is its own competitive advantage in the marketplace, he says.
Finally, figure out the best way to communicate the value that your health system delivers. "We all go shopping, and we know that value means getting the highest quality for the best price," says Gundling. "But as patients, we haven't figured out what we want yet."
Lola Butcher is a freelance writer and editor based in Missouri.
See related article: Lessons Learned from Hospital Transparency Pioneers
Publication Date: Thursday, May 17, 2012
Brian Kueppers, founder and CEO, Apex, discusses the importance of a robust patient payment strategy in boosting organization revenue and enhancing patient satisfaction.
Brian Grazzini, CFO, HealthPort, describes the importance of efficient and compliant information exchange and audit management in helping HIM staff spend less time on paperwork and more on mission-critical projects.
Cindy Matthews, executive vice president, Community Hospital Corporation, discusses how rural and community hospitals can use collaborative partnering to position for success through tough market conditions.
Rick Heise, senior vice president, revenue cycle, at Cerner Corporation, discusses the importance of integrating clinical and financial data to excel in health care’s changing payment environment.
Dale Hockel, senior vice president of operations, and Jim Fanelli, CFO, TriMedx, share strategies for elevating clinical engineering through innovative management programs.
Russ Graney, founder and CEO for Aidin, and John Laursen, head of business development for Aidin, share insights on how to improve care transitions between acute and post-acute care settings and incentivize high-quality patient outcomes.
Scott Elston, strategic accounts manager, GE Healthcare Services, describes how substantial cost reduction in health care requires rethinking business strategy and asset use.
Robert Williams, MD, director, Deloitte Consulting LLP, and Arielle Freiberger, product strategist, ConvergeHEALTH by Deloitte, explain how sophisticated retrospective, real-time, and predictive data analytics can inform decision making to reduce costs and improve care.
Stuart Hanson, director of business development (healthcare solutions) at Citi Retail Services, discusses how improving the payment experience can benefit consumers and healthcare providers.
Scott Schmidt, vice president, Cerner RevWorks, LLC, shares insights on best practices for maximizing a revenue cycle management partnership.
HFMA's print, email, online, and mobile opportunities provide you maximum reach and impact. We will work with you to build a plan that meets your needs. Contact a sales rep.
HFMA offers online, email, and print opportunities to help you recruit the most talented healthcare finance professionals. Place your classified ads today.
Drive down costs while improving quality in a reform environment.
Stay informed about new directions in healthcare finance. Share tools and strategies for improving performance. Be an active participant in your profession. Together, we’ll reshape the business and practice of healthcare. Join us.
©2015 Copyright Healthcare Financial Management Association
HFMA.org is best viewed using IE9 or the latest versions of Chrome, Firefox, and Safari.
Join HFMA today and enjoy: