Blog | Patient Experience

New research suggests there’s no need to worry that patient experience surveys lead to low-value healthcare

Blog | Patient Experience

New research suggests there’s no need to worry that patient experience surveys lead to low-value healthcare

The strongest statistical correlation found in the study indicates that low-value care leads to more time spent in the waiting room.

Findings from a new study may assuage concerns that delivery of low-value care is encouraged through the use of patient experience ratings in payment formulas.

For a study published in JAMA Internal Medicine, researchers examined the following in primary care settings:

  • Medicare fee-for-service claims spanning 2007 through 2014 among more than 100,000 professionals
  • Patient experience reports based on 2010 through 2015 responses to the CAHPS survey, which can factor into payment as a component of the Medicare Shared Savings Program and the Merit-based Incentive Payment System

Relevant services were identified using a previously published methodology that defined low-value services as providing minimal clinical benefit in specific scenarios.

The key findings

Although some associations between exposure to low-value care and CAHPS scores “were statistically significant, their magnitudes were substantially smaller than those typically considered meaningful in other CAHPS literature and were inconsistent in direction across levels of low-value service exposure,” the authors wrote.

If anything, the strongest statistical association indicates that providing low-value care can lead to worse performance on surveys: “More low-value care exposure was associated with more frequent reports of having to wait more than 15 minutes after the scheduled time for an appointment.”

That relationship may arise because “poorly organized or overwhelmed practices substitute wasteful services for higher-value services that require more cognitive effort and clinician time,” the authors theorized.

The bottom line

The authors acknowledged that their study does not show a causal relationship between provision of low-value care and patient experience ratings. Still, their findings “may help reduce the use of low-value care that is provided to appease patients who would be equally satisfied with less wasteful care and help alleviate concerns that patient dissatisfaction should inhibit waste reduction under alternative payment models.”

About the Author

Nick Hut

is a senior editor with HFMA, Westchester, Ill. (

Sign up for a free guest account and get access to five free articles every month.


Related Articles | Patient Experience

Article | Patient Access

Health Services Financing helps providers offer all patients a touchless financing program

One company uses its patient financing program to address patient access to care and the rising cost of healthcare, two of healthcare’s biggest challenges.

News | Patient Access

Healthcare News of Note: Providers should continue forward movement on improving digital patient access, survey suggests

Healthcare News of Note for healthcare finance professionals is a roundup of recent news articles: Expectations for convenient access to care in the pandemic era, a look at ICU bed use across the U.S., and the cost of hospitalizations among unvaccinated adults.

Business Profile | Operations and Other Technology

Single-use endoscopes offer a safe way for healthcare providers to catch up on backlog of nonemergent care procedures

One company focuses on growing endoscopy departments of healthcare organizations with single-use devices. Learn about the benefits of single-use endoscopes and how to take advantage of these products.

Article | Patient Experience

Virtual Intake Management® by PELITAS provides a digital experience with self-service options helping providers financially clear more than 75% of patients before service

One company explains how technology solutions help improve patient experience, maximize revenue and eliminate efficiencies throughout the revenue cycle.