Course | Overview | Compliance

This course covers a set of four compliance risk areas identified by the Office of Inspector General (OIG) that healthcare providers need to be aware of before they submit healthcare claims to federal agencies for approval. The course also ...

Save
Course | Overview | Compliance

This course provides a general discussion and overview of reimbursement provided by Medicare under the outpatient prospective payment system. It also discusses the use of ambulatory payment classifications in the outpatient prospective paym...

Save
Course | Overview | Compliance

This course discusses the regulation and accreditation of the healthcare field. It provides overviews of various legislation, such as the HMO Act of 1973, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 (ERISA), state regulations, and t...

Save
Course | Overview | Compliance

This course addresses the rise of corporate compliance programs in healthcare organizations, including their complexity and importance. It reviews the components of corporate compliance programs and the role of a compliance officer to know ...

Save
Course | Overview | Compliance

This course explains the basics of HIPAA's Privacy Rule and what you need to consider when handling patients' Protected Health Information (PHI). It also outlines the rights that patients have under HIPAA.

Save
News | Compliance

Mandates related to pricing, Medicare participation lead hospital concerns over healthcare IT proposed rules

News | Compliance

Mandates related to pricing, Medicare participation lead hospital concerns over healthcare IT proposed rules

  • Hospitals opposed a proposed ONC requirement that they provide pricing information for each patient and procedure.
  • Instead, hospitals urged that private and public insurance plans provide out-of-pocket price information to their beneficiaries.
  • Hospitals warned against requiring electronic data exchange of specific information, citing a lack of infrastructure.

Hospitals supported many of the transparency goals of two proposed healthcare IT rules, but two areas drew sharp concerns.

In comments due June 3, hospitals and their advocates warned of far-reaching consequences if the Trump administration finalizes proposed rules to change Medicare and Medicaid conditions of participation (CoP). The new rules would require exchange of specific patient electronic health information (EHI) and that records include pricing information.

Concerns about the price-information requirement

Specifically, a proposed rule on interoperability from the Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (ONC) sought comments on including within required EHI “price information,” which was left undefined, as part of requirements to prevent information blocking. 

Hospitals raised concerns about the proposal, including that it:

  • Fails to enhance competition based on quality and value, since price is not a proxy for quality
  • Creates a costly unfunded mandate by requiring hospitals to provide prices for each patient and procedure
  • Violates the First Amendment by compelling disclosure of confidential commercial information
  • Inhibits competition by creating a platform for price fixing

“Health plans would know what every other health plan was paying and could use that information indirectly to collude and drive prices below competitive levels, thereby reducing the incentives for actual competition in the marketplace and threatening the viability of some of the nation’s most vulnerable hospitals,” wrote the American Hospital Association.

Like other hospital-sector stakeholders, HFMA questioned both ONC’s legal authority to create the price-listing requirement and the requirement’s usefulness for insured patients, who prioritize out-of-pocket costs.

“HFMA’s members believe the most appropriate source of information for commercially insured patients/members is their health plan because it will have the necessary data to provide the most accurate, relevant estimate,” HFMA wrote in a letter to ONC.

Similarly, the Michigan Health and Hospital Association urged that private and public insurance plans provide out-of-pocket price information to their beneficiaries, with providers offering patient-specific out-of-pocket information to uninsured patients.

Trinity Health warned against using Medicare prices as a reference tool because such information could be misleading to non-Medicare patients and shoppers.

“Showing the rate Medicare pays may cause patient confusion and suspicion of the hospital’s pricing fairness. Hospitals with true procedure-level cost knowledge submit that Medicare reimbursement does not come close to covering their current costs,” wrote Tina Weatherwax Grant, JD, vice president of public policy and advocacy for the health system.

Alternate approaches could include federally developed or supported “real-time benefit tools that provide accurate out-of-pocket costs at the point of care,” wrote the Medical Group Management Association.

Hospitals also challenge CoP proposal

The Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) released a separate but related proposed rule related to health information. It would amend the Medicare and Medicaid CoPs for hospitals, critical access hospitals and psychiatric hospitals to require the electronic exchange of admission, discharge and transfer (ADT) information. Additionally, CoPs would require hospitals to provide patient-event notifications.

Hospital concerns with the CoP provisions included that they:

  • Assume an infrastructure allowing routine exchange of such information even though such an infrastructure has not been built
  • Create conflicting and confusing hospital requirements relative to the ONC information-blocking rule
  • Move beyond existing information-sharing requirements to focus on the mechanism by which information must be shared
  • Create liability under the False Claims Act for hospitals that certified they were not an information blocker under the Promoting Interoperability Program (PIP)

Michigan-based Spectrum Health was among the health systems urging CMS to focus on building the PIP data-exchange infrastructure rather than layering additional requirements on hospitals.

“Utilizing the CoP program is an unnecessary burden for enhancing hospital use of these feeds,” wrote Jason Joseph, chief information officer for Spectrum Health.

CMS’s assertion that the ADT data requirement would impose minimal, one-time costs on hospitals was challenged by the College of Health Information Management Executives (CHIME) and the Association for Executives in Health Information Technology (AEHIT).

“We believe CMS has significantly underestimated the complexity of meeting this mandate, and we do not agree with the agency’s estimation that this should require little effort and be a one-time cost,” CHIME and AEHIT wrote to CMS.

The groups urged CMS at a minimum to give hospitals three years to prepare before the requirement takes effect.

The hospital advocacy group Premier recommended that CMS instead use existing policy levers to establish a system of event notifications and that it work to improve existing infrastructure in support of health data exchange.

About the Authors

Rich Daly, HFMA senior writer/editor

is based in the Washington, D.C., office. Follow Rich on Twitter: @rdalyhealthcare

Advertisements

Related Articles | Compliance

Business Profile | Revenue Cycle Technology

Ontario Systems: Helping Healthcare Organizations Realize the Benefits of an Accountable Collections Team

Steve Scibetta, vice president and general manager at Ontario Systems, offers strategies for optimizing the revenue cycle, including employing supportive accounts receivable technology and building an accountable collections team.

Business Profile | Medical Necessity

Enjoin: Enabling Holistic Clinical Documentation Improvement

James Fee, MD, CEO of Enjoin, discusses the importance of holistic clinical documentation to realize success with existing fee-for-service payment models, as well as value-based care and population health initiatives.

Blog | Telemedicine

University of Rochester: Using telemedicine to reach more patients with Parkinson’s disease

An academic medical center’s efforts to bring telemedicine to patients with Parkinson’s disease has reduced costs and improved outcomes.

News | Compliance

Small practices lack support personnel for frail elderly patients

Despite recommendations for practices to add support personnel to coordinate the care of their frail elderly patients, few small, independent practices employ such staff, new research found.