News | Coronavirus

The vaccine mandate for healthcare workers is back in place for half the country following an appeals court ruling

News | Coronavirus

The vaccine mandate for healthcare workers is back in place for half the country following an appeals court ruling

The issue seems destined to be decided by the U.S. Supreme Court.

The status of the federal vaccine mandate for healthcare workers became more muddled on Wednesday, with an appeals court reinstating the mandate for 26 states.

The New Orleans-based 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a prior court decision to issue an injunction on the mandate should apply only to the states that had been part of the lawsuit in question.

The states covered by the injunction are the 14 plaintiffs in the case, while a separate injunction pertains to 10 states in a different case.

In its ruling, the three-judge panel (including two appointees by President Barack Obama and one by President George W. Bush) indicated the Supreme Court likely will be called on to issue a comprehensive national ruling.

Pending further rulings, health systems with facilities in multiple states now may be faced with implementing the mandate at some sites and considering whether to make vaccination voluntary at others. As of Wednesday afternoon, CMS had not confirmed whether it would seek to enforce the mandate where doing so is permitted.

Injunctions on the mandate remain in place in the following states:
















New Hampshire

North Dakota



South Carolina

South Dakota


West Virginia


About the Author

Nick Hut

is a senior editor with HFMA, Westchester, Ill. (

Sign up for a free guest account and get access to five free articles every month.


Related Articles | Coronavirus

News | Coronavirus

The COVID-19 vaccine mandate for healthcare workers can take effect nationwide, Supreme Court says

The court lifted injunctions that had halted implementation of the COVID-19 vaccine mandate in half the country, leaving hospitals and other affected providers with likely only a few weeks to begin complying.

News | Labor Cost Management

Healthcare labor update: Employment data and research findings underscore ongoing challenges

As highlighted in new employment data and new studies, the healthcare labor market continues to constrain hospitals.

Blog | Healthcare Business Trends

Hospital margins increased in November, but labor expenses remained a drag on finances

A skewed labor market continued to affect hospital finances in November even as operating margins improved from October.

News | Coronavirus

CMS now says hospitals in half the country must abide by the COVID-19 vaccine mandate starting in late January

The status of the COVID-19 vaccine mandate for healthcare workers took another twist, with CMS stating it will look to enforce the mandate within a month in 25 states and Washington, D.C.