Healthcare Finance and Business Strategy

Debate on hospital merger antitrust review draws focus to access and margins

A report says hospital consolidation reviews should account for financial stability, payer mix and care access, while policymakers continue to scrutinize the issue of competition in healthcare.

Published September 18, 2026 8:33 am

Amid recurring criticism about the impact of hospital-led consolidation, a new report recommends that regulators look beyond price increases in evaluating mergers within the sector.

Commissioned by the American Hospital Association and prepared by Kaufman Hall, the report states that merger reviews should also consider hospital financial stability, access to care and the impact on Medicare and Medicaid patients.

As part of the report, the authors examined more than 200 counties that have only two hospitals and found that hospitals in those counties are not always direct competitors. The hospitals often provide complementary services rather than competing across all service lines.

Measures traditionally used by regulators to gauge market concentration from prospective mergers, such as the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index, may not fully capture that dynamic, the authors argued.

Congressional hearing scrutinizes hospital consolidation and payment incentives

There was a less sympathetic outlook toward hospital-led merger-and-acquisition (M&A) activity during a recent field hearing conducted by Republicans on a subcommittee of the House Judiciary Committee (members said their Democratic colleagues were invited to the Sept. 14 event in Charlotte, N.C., but did not attend). The portions of the hearing that examined healthcare M&A focused more on vertical integration than on hospital-hospital mergers.

Among the ideas discussed at the hearing was the notion that site-specific payment gives incentives for hospitals to acquire physician practices and other healthcare entities because a hospital-owned facility frequently can charge a significantly higher rate for the same service. Site-neutral payment policies are one way that legislators and regulators have tried to counter that trend.

“The modern hospital sector is increasingly dominated by regional or multistate health systems that own hospitals, physician practices, outpatient departments, imaging centers, infusion sites and other facilities,” Brian Blase, PhD, president of the conservative Paragon Health Institute, said in written testimony for the hearing.

Rep. Bob Onder (R-Mo.) cited the hospital perspective that site-based payment differentials are merited, among other reasons, because conventional hospitals have to accommodate all patients, whereas alternative facilities such as physician-owned hospitals theoretically can select their patients based on payer mix or other factors. Brian Miller, MD, associate professor of medicine at Johns Hopkins University, responded that half of physician-owned hospitals are general acute-care or community hospitals.

“Community hospitals don’t exist as a business without Medicare or Medicaid,” Miller said.

Certificate-of-need laws emerge as a policy focus

Panelists described the need to improve competition through policy. For example, they said certificate-of-need (CON) laws should be reformed as a way to increase competition. As applied in 35 states and Washington, D.C., the laws require state approval to open or expand a healthcare facility.

“This means that healthcare providers cannot quickly invest in improving the healthcare infrastructure in a community,” said Rep. Scott Fitzgerald (R-Wis.), chair of the subcommittee. “They must ask for permission from the government first, and the answer is often no.”

Miller said the laws even determine whether a capital purchase such as an MRI is merited.

“We have 25 years of solid economic research that shows that certificate of need, when in place, raises costs, restricts access and reduces quality,” said Miller, who made similar points during a recent meeting of the Medicare Payment Advisory Commission (MedPAC).

One policy consideration is to link Medicaid federal matching rates or even Medicare hospital payment rates “to create incentives for state legislatures to get rid of anticompetitive laws,” Miller said.

Policymakers also should promote the growth of independent physician practices as a counterweight to consolidation, Miller said. One step in that direction would be to add a managed care exception to the Stark Law (i.e., the Physician Self-Referral Law), meaning financial arrangements and referrals within networks would be shielded from federal self-referral penalties.

Merger review raises questions about payer mix and access to care

Hospital mergers raise prices by between 7% and 9%, and by 17% for interstate mergers, Miller said, citing published studies. However, the Kaufman Hall report posits that antitrust reviews focus too much on the commercial insurance pricing impact.

When counting Medicare Advantage (MA) enrollees, nearly 60% of hospital patient days are associated with Medicare or Medicaid patients, according to the authors’ analysis of Medicare cost-report data (with MA days pulled out of the commercial bucket using 2023 U.S. Census Bureau data). Prices thus do not substantially impact the majority of patients, given that reimbursement for those patients is largely tied to government payment rates.

“When a merger is blocked because of potential increases in commercial insurance prices, we cannot ignore what will happen to Medicare and Medicaid patients whose prices won’t change, but their access to care will,” wrote Chad Golder, AHA general counsel and secretary, in a blog post accompanying the report.

Mergers can be essential to preventing hospital or service-line closures and protecting access to care, the Kaufman Hall authors wrote. Hospitals targeted for acquisition typically face greater financial pressure than average hospitals, including because their payer mix tends to have a higher percentage of government-insured patients, the authors wrote, citing their review of 88 M&A transactions that were canceled since 2006 (the report does not specify that antitrust scrutiny was behind the cancellations).

Canceled hospital deals can intensify financial pressure, report finds

Ramifications when a merger has to be canceled include a 50% decline in operating profit margin and a 38% drop in days cash on hand for the target hospital in the year following cancellation, according to Kaufman Hall’s analysis (a graphic in the report puts the margin decrease at 52%). Failed deals can increase the risk of service reductions, workforce cuts, bankruptcy and closure.

“Blocking or abandoning a transaction does not return the parties to some frictionless status quo,” Golder wrote. “It can leave a struggling hospital to confront the same financial problems, but now with fewer options for solving them.”

The impact on communities may be especially profound because many hospitals seeking to be acquired serve older, lower-income or medically vulnerable populations, according to the report. Preventing mergers can threaten access to care for people who need it most, the authors indicate.

Advertisements

googletag.cmd.push( function () { googletag.display( 'hfma-gpt-text1' ); } );
googletag.cmd.push( function () { googletag.display( 'hfma-gpt-text2' ); } );
googletag.cmd.push( function () { googletag.display( 'hfma-gpt-text3' ); } );
googletag.cmd.push( function () { googletag.display( 'hfma-gpt-text4' ); } );
googletag.cmd.push( function () { googletag.display( 'hfma-gpt-text5' ); } );
googletag.cmd.push( function () { googletag.display( 'hfma-gpt-text6' ); } );
googletag.cmd.push( function () { googletag.display( 'hfma-gpt-text7' ); } );
googletag.cmd.push( function () { googletag.display( 'hfma-gpt-leaderboard' ); } );

{{ loadingHeading }}

{{ loadingSubHeading }}

We’re having trouble logging you in.

For assistance, contact our Member Services Team.

Your session has expired.

Please reload the page and try again.