On Demand Webinar | Basic | Coronavirus
<div>As COVID-19 pandemic materialized and spread, it has changed so much about healthcare delivery, how we prepare, and how we go about our daily lives.&nbsp; We are reminded how fragile our health and the healthcare system can be. As an i...
On Demand Webinar | Intermediate | Coronavirus
The COVID-19 pandemic is ravaging healthcare facilities, which is partly due to a lack of personal protective equipment (PPE) and other critical supplies.&nbsp; Vulnerabilities in the supply chain have been exposed. As such, hospitals shoul...
On Demand Webinar | Basic | Coronavirus
In the wake of COVID-19, many healthcare providers that traditionally relied on physical office space had to quickly adapt their operations to meet regulatory guidelines and ensure the safety of their employees by shifting to remote work. O...
On Demand Webinar | Basic | Coronavirus
Relying on aggressive financial policies and collection tactics won't help your organization adapt to the "patient as payer" model, especially after the pandemic.&nbsp; Instead, you need a strategy that helps patients easily navigate the fi...
On Demand Webinar | Basic | Coronavirus
<div>The COVID-19 pandemic is causing major economic disruptions and has left many health systems struggling to find ways to drive cash supply and forecast budgets. The ability to pivot and prepare a financial operating plan that provides a...
News | Coronavirus

Critical access hospitals will avoid Medicare cuts stemming from Paycheck Protection Program loans, Verma says

News | Coronavirus

Critical access hospitals will avoid Medicare cuts stemming from Paycheck Protection Program loans, Verma says

  • CMS will not count Paycheck Protection Program loans against rural providers’ expenses when calculating Medicare payments, the agency’s administrator says.
  • The announcement followed advocacy by hospitals and their allies.
  • Four rural hospitals have closed since the start of the pandemic, supporters note.

Although some critical access hospitals (CAHs) may have heard from Medicare contractors that they needed to deduct federal coronavirus loans from their expenses reported to Medicare, that policy will not apply, according to CMS Administrator Seema Verma.

Verma recently tweeted that 1,350 CAHs should not expect loans from the Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) to be deducted from their expense-related Medicare payments.

“CMS does not intend for Paycheck Protection Program funds to impact Medicare payments to rural hospitals,” Verma wrote. “More guidance will be out soon that’ll explain how hospitals should report those funds on their Medicare Cost Reports.”

Deducting Medicare loans from Medicare cost reports would have cost rural hospitals millions of dollars in lost payments, advisers say.

“We consider this a victory for rural health,” Brock Slabach, senior vice president for the National Rural Health Association (NRHA), said in an interview. “This only applies to critical access hospitals because we’re the only ones who are paid under costs.”

MACs had issued warnings about loans

Slabach said some CAHs already had heard from Medicare administrative contractors (MACs) that they must subtract PPP loans from their salary and wage expenses when seeking future Medicare payments. However, CMS had not issued any public guidance on the issue.

Medicare patients encompass on average about 50% to 60% of CAH patient populations and associated costs, which are used to calculate Medicare payments, said Dave Snow, JD, an attorney for Hall Render.

“They’re basically cutting your Medicare reimbursement in half or taking back half of the CARES Act money,” Snow said. “That’s totally the wrong answer under existing law and cost report rules.”

The PPP loans, approved through the CARES Act, aimed to incentivize small businesses to keep their workers on payroll by forgiving the loans if workers were retained. Rural hospitals and other small hospitals cited the loans as a key tool for weathering the financial fallout from the COVID-19 pandemic.

As of Aug. 8, the Small Business Administration reported that 532,775 PPP loans were made to “health care and social assistance” entities, with those organizations receiving $67.8 billion, or 12.9% of total payments.

The clarification from CMS is expected soon because hospitals with fiscal years ending June 30 would have to use PPP loan information to complete their Medicare cost reports due Nov. 30, Snow said.

“Nobody is recognizing it as a reduction in costs under normal accounting through GAAP,” Snow said, referring to CAHs.

Hospitals and others push for favorable policy on PPP loan forgiveness

The clarification from Verma followed entreaties from a number of national groups, including NRHA, about the adverse financial impact of counting the loans against expenses. The National Rural Lenders Roundtable (NRLR) warned Verma in a letter that a Medicare labor cost offset could result in a loss of 70% to 80% of a rural healthcare provider’s PPP loan-forgiveness amount.

“Prior to this PPP funding, these rural healthcare providers were operating at the narrowest of financial margins,” NRLR wrote.

The lender group noted four rural hospitals have been forced to close since the start of the pandemic.

Sen. Susan Collins (R-Maine) wrote Verma in a July 29 letter, co-signed by two other senators, that “any effort to recapture or disallow loan forgiveness — which is what reports indicate the CMS interpretation would do — would defeat the goal of the PPP and threaten the livelihood of small providers amidst a global pandemic.”

The senators also wrote, “Recognizing that millions of jobs were at risk, we deliberately designed these loans to be forgivable so long as employers met the conditions set out in the law, and used the money to keep staff paid and employed.”

About the Author

Rich Daly, HFMA Senior Writer and Editor,

is based in the Washington, D.C., office. Follow Rich on Twitter: @rdalyhealthcare.


Related Articles | Coronavirus

Issue At a Glance | Health Plan Payment and Reimbursement

Q&A: Humana expands value-based payment push

One MA health plan discusses how it’s pushing further into value-based payment and what that means for providers.

News | Financial Leadership

How leading health system CFOs are staying agile on the road to recovery

Making strategic decisions in the current environment is difficult, but CFOs are leading their organizations by creating a more performance-based culture and adopting an agile financial planning approach.

News | Medicare Payment and Reimbursement

Proposed change to Medicare E/M payment leads to disagreement among both providers and health plans

Medicare physician payment changes for evaluation and management could have dire financial repercussions for some practices, providers warn.

Blog | Coronavirus

HHS announces Phase 3 CARES Act Provider Relief Funding

The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services will accept applications for Phase 3 General Distributions of provider relief funds Oct. 5 – Nov. 6.